Marketing Deal Offers

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, 9 June 2010

Using a Purchase Funnel to Measure Marketing Effectiveness: Better than Last-Click Attribution But Far From Perfect

Posted on 06:52 by Unknown
Summary: Many vendors are now proposing to move beyond "last click" attribution to measure the impact of advertising on movement of customers through a sequence of buying stages. This is a definite improvement but not a complete solution.

Marketers have long struggled to measure the impact of individual promotions. Even online marketing, where every click can be captured, and often tracked back to a specific person, doesn’t automatically solve the problem. Merely tracking clicks doesn’t answer the deeper question of the causal relationships among different marketing contacts.

Current shorthand for the issue is “last click attribution” – as in, “why last click attribution isn’t enough”. Of course, vendors only start pointing out a problem when they’re ready to sell you a solution. So it won’t come as a surprise that a new consensus seems to be emerging on how to measure the value of multiple marketing contacts.

The solution boils down to this: classify different contacts as related to the different stages in the buying process and then measure their effectiveness at moving customers from one stage to the next. This is no different from the “sales funnel” that sales managers have long measured, nor from the AIDA model (awareness, interest, desire, action) that structures traditional brand marketing. All that’s new, if anything, is the claim to assign a precise value to individual messages.

Examples of vendors taking this approach include:

- Marketo recently announced new "Revenue Cycle Analytics" marketing measurement features with its customary hoopla. The conceptual foundation of Marketo’s approach is that it tracks the movement of customers through the buying stages. Although this itself isn’t particularly novel, Marketo has added some significant technology in the form of a reporting database that can reconstruct the status of a given customer at various points in the time. Although this is pretty standard among business intelligence systems, few if any of Marketo's competitors offer anything similar.

- Clear Saleing bills itself as an “advertising analytics platform”. Its secret sauce is defining a set of advertising goals (introducer, influencer, or closer) and then specifying which goal each promotion supports. Marketers can then calculate their spending against the different goals and estimate the impact of changes in the allocation. Credit within each goal can be distributed equally among promotions or allocated according to user-defined weights. While such allocation is a major advance for most marketers, it’s still far from perfect because the weights are not based on directly measuring each ad's actual impact.

- Leadforce1 offers a range of typical B2B marketing automation features, but its main distinction is to infer each buyer's position in a four-stage funnel (discovery, evaluation, use, and affinity) based on Web behaviors. The specific approach is to link keywords within Web content to the stages and then track which content each person views. The details are worth their own blog post, but the key point, again, is that the contents are assigned to sales stages and the system tracks each buyer’s progress through those stages. Although the primary focus of LeadForce1 is managing relationships with individuals, the vendor also describes using the data to assess campaign ROI.

Compared with last click attribution, use of sales stages is a major improvement. But it’s far from the ultimate solution. So far as I know, none of the current products does any statistical analysis, such as a regression model, to estimate the true impact of messages at either the individual or campaign level. They either rely on user-specified weights or simply treat all messages within each stage as a group. This lack of detail makes campaign optimization impossible: at best, it allows stage optimization.

Even more fundamentally, stage analysis assumes that each message applies to a single marketing stage. This is surely untrue. As brand marketers constantly remind us, a well-designed message can increase lifetime purchases among all recipients, whether or not they are current customers. It’s equally true that some messages affect certain stages more than others. But to ignore the impact on all stages except one is an oversimplification that can easily lead to false conclusions and poor marketing decisions.

Stage-based attribution has its merits. It gives marketers a rough sense of how spending is balanced across the purchase stages and lets them measure movement and attrition from one stage to the next. Combined with careful testing, it could give insight into the impact of individual marketing programs. But marketers should recognize its limits and keep pressing for solutions that measure the full impact of each program on all their customers.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in last click attribution, marketing measurement, marketing ROI, sales funnel | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • eBay Offers $2.4 Billion for GSI Commerce: More Support for Marketing Automation
    eBay ’s $2.4 billion offer for e-commerce services giant GSI Commerce has been described largely in terms of helping eBay to compete with ...
  • Infer Keeps It Simple: B2B Lead Scores and Nothing Else
    I’ve nearly finished gathering information from vendors for my new study on Customer Data Platform systems and have started to look for patt...
  • NICE Buys Causata to Extend Its Customer Experience Management Position
    So, there I was around 7:30 Eastern time this morning, sending out reminder notices to vendors I need to interview for an upcoming report on...
  • thinkAnalytics Helps Marketers Optimize Customer Treatments
    Summary: thinkAnalytics provides a robust decision engine to help make optimal recommendations across channels. Too bad more people don...
  • Selligent Brings a New B2C Marketing Automation Option to the U.S.
    I’m writing this post on my old DOS-based WordPerfect software, to get in the proper mood for discussing business-to-consumer marketing auto...
  • So Many Measures, So Little Time
    I’ve been collating lists of marketing performance metrics from different sources, which is exactly as much fun as it sounds. One result th...
  • 4 Marketing Tech Trends To Watch in 2014
    I'm not a big fan of year-end summaries and forecasts, mostly because I produce summaries and forecasts all year round.  But I pulled to...
  • Marketo Raises Another $50 Million: Where Does the Money Go?
    Marketo this morning announced a new $50 million funding round, almost exactly one year to the day after raising $25 million in November 2...
  • James Taylor on His New Book
    A few months ago, James Taylor of Fair Isaac asked me to look over a proof of Smart (Enough) Systems , a book he has co-written with indust...
  • Vocus Marketing Suite: Still Mostly Social But Marketing Automation is On the Way
    If you’ve heard of Vocus at all, it’s probably as vendor serving public relations professionals. Its core offerings include a huge databas...

Categories

  • [x+1]
  • 1010Data
  • 2009 trends
  • 2010 predictions
  • 2011 predictions
  • 2013 marketing automation revenues
  • 2014 predictions
  • account data in marketing systems
  • acquisitions
  • acquistions
  • act-on software
  • active conversion
  • activeconversion
  • acxiom
  • ad agencies
  • ad servers
  • adam needles
  • adobe
  • adometry
  • advertising effectiveness
  • advocate management
  • affiliate marketing
  • agilone
  • aida model
  • aimatch
  • algorithmic attribution
  • alterian
  • analysis systems
  • analytical database
  • analytical databases
  • analytical systems
  • analytics tools
  • app exchange
  • app marketplace
  • application design
  • aprimo
  • are
  • artificial intelligence
  • ascend2
  • asset management
  • assetlink
  • atg
  • attribution analysis
  • attribution models
  • automated decisions
  • automated dialog
  • automated modeling
  • autonomy
  • b2b demand generation
  • b2b demand generation systems
  • b2b email marketing benchmarks
  • b2b lead scoring
  • b2b marketing
  • b2b marketing automation
  • b2b marketing automation industry consolidation
  • b2b marketing automation industry growth rate
  • b2b marketing automation revenues
  • b2b marketing automation systems
  • b2b marketing automation vendor rankings
  • b2b marketing data
  • b2b marketing industry consolidation
  • b2b marketing strategy
  • b2b marketing system comparison
  • b2c marketing automation
  • b2c marketing automation vendors
  • balanced scorecard
  • balihoo
  • barriers to marketing success
  • barry devlin
  • beanstalk data
  • behavior detection
  • behavior identification
  • behavior targeting
  • behavioral data
  • behavioral targeting
  • big data
  • birst
  • bislr
  • blogging software
  • brand experience
  • brand marketing
  • business intelligence
  • business intelligence software
  • business intelligence systems
  • business marketing
  • businses case
  • callidus
  • campaign flow
  • campaign management
  • campaign management software
  • causata
  • cdi
  • cdp
  • channel management
  • channel marketing
  • channel partner management
  • chordiant
  • cio priorities
  • clickdimensions
  • clicksquared
  • clientxclient
  • cloud computing
  • cmo surveys
  • cms
  • collaboration software
  • column data store
  • column-oriented database
  • columnar database
  • community management
  • compare marketing automation vendors
  • compiled data
  • complex event processing
  • consumer marketing
  • contact center systems
  • content aggregation
  • content distribution
  • content grazing
  • content management
  • content marketing
  • content matrix
  • content recommendations
  • content selections
  • content syndication
  • context automation
  • conversen
  • coremetrics
  • crm
  • crm integration
  • CRM lead scores
  • crm software
  • crm systems
  • crmevolution
  • cross-channel marketing
  • crowd sourcing
  • custom content
  • custom media
  • customer database
  • customer analysis
  • customer data
  • customer data integration
  • customer data management
  • customer data platform
  • customer data platforms
  • customer data quality
  • customer data warehouse
  • customer database
  • customer experience
  • customer experience management
  • customer experience matrix
  • customer information
  • customer management
  • customer management software
  • customer management systems
  • customer metrics
  • customer relationship management
  • customer satisfaction
  • customer success
  • customer support
  • cxc matrix
  • dashboards
  • data analysis
  • data cleaning
  • data cleansing
  • data enhancement
  • data integration
  • data loading
  • data mining
  • data mining and terrorism
  • data quality
  • data transformation tools
  • data visualization
  • data warehouse
  • database management
  • database marketing
  • database marketing systems
  • database technology
  • dataflux
  • datallegro
  • datamentors
  • david raab
  • david raab webinar
  • david raab whitepaper
  • day software
  • decision engiens
  • decision engines
  • decision management
  • decision science
  • dell
  • demand generation
  • demand generation implementation
  • demand generation industry
  • demand generation industry growth rate
  • demand generation industry size
  • demand generation industry trends
  • demand generation marketbright
  • demand generation marketing automation
  • demand generation software
  • demand generation software revenues
  • demand generation systems
  • demand generation vendors
  • demandforce
  • digiday
  • digital marketing
  • digital marketing systems
  • digital messaging
  • distributed marketing
  • dmp
  • dreamforce
  • dreamforce 2012
  • dynamic content
  • ease of use
  • ebay
  • eglue
  • eloqua
  • eloqua10
  • elqoua ipo
  • email
  • email marketing
  • email service providers
  • engagement engine
  • enteprise marketing management
  • enterprise decision management
  • enterprise marketing management
  • enterprise software
  • entiera
  • epiphany
  • ETL
  • eTrigue
  • event detection
  • event stream processing
  • event-based marketing
  • exacttarget
  • facebook
  • feature checklists
  • flow charts
  • fractional attribution
  • freemium
  • future of marketing automation
  • g2crowd
  • gainsight
  • Genius.com
  • genoo
  • geotargeting
  • gleanster
  • governance
  • grosocial
  • gsi commerce
  • high performance analytics
  • hiring consultants
  • hosted software
  • hosted systems
  • hubspot
  • ibm
  • impact of internet on selling
  • importance of sales execution
  • in-memory database
  • in-site search
  • inbound marketing
  • industry consolidation
  • industry growth rate
  • industry size
  • industry trends
  • influitive
  • infor
  • information cards
  • infusioncon 2013
  • infusionsoft
  • innovation
  • integrated customer management
  • integrated marketing management
  • integrated marketing management systems
  • integrated marketing systems
  • integrated systems
  • intent measurement
  • interaction advisor
  • interaction management
  • interestbase
  • interwoven
  • intuit
  • IP address lookup
  • jbara
  • jesubi
  • king fish media
  • kwanzoo
  • kxen
  • kynetx
  • large company marketing automation
  • last click attribution
  • lead capture
  • lead generation
  • lead management
  • lead management software
  • lead management systems
  • lead managment
  • lead ranking
  • lead scoring
  • lead scoring models
  • leadforce1
  • leadformix
  • leading marketing automation systems
  • leadlander
  • leadlife
  • leadmd
  • leftbrain dga
  • lifecycle analysis
  • lifecycle reporting
  • lifetime value
  • lifetime value model
  • local marketing automation
  • loopfuse
  • low cost marketing software
  • low-cost marketing software
  • loyalty systems
  • lyzasoft
  • makesbridge
  • manticore technology
  • mapreduce
  • market consolidation
  • market software
  • market2lead
  • marketbight
  • marketbright
  • marketgenius
  • marketing analysis
  • marketing analytics
  • marketing and sales integration
  • marketing automation
  • marketing automation adoption
  • marketing automation benefits
  • marketing automation consolidation
  • marketing automation cost
  • marketing automation deployment
  • marketing automation features
  • marketing automation industry
  • marketing automation industry growth rate
  • marketing automation industry trends
  • marketing automation market share
  • marketing automation market size
  • marketing automation maturity model
  • marketing automation net promoter score. marketing automation effectiveness
  • marketing automation pricing
  • marketing automation software
  • marketing automation software evaluation
  • marketing automation success factors
  • marketing automation system deployment
  • marketing automation system evaluation
  • marketing automation system features
  • marketing automation system selection
  • marketing automation system usage
  • marketing automation systems
  • marketing automation trends
  • marketing automation user satisfaction
  • marketing automation vendor financials
  • marketing automation vendor selection
  • marketing automation vendor strategies
  • marketing automion
  • marketing best practices
  • marketing cloud
  • marketing content
  • marketing data
  • marketing data management
  • marketing database
  • marketing database management
  • marketing education
  • marketing execution
  • marketing funnel
  • marketing integration
  • marketing lead stages
  • marketing management
  • marketing measurement
  • marketing mix models
  • marketing operating system
  • marketing operations
  • marketing optimization
  • marketing performance
  • marketing performance measurement
  • marketing platforms
  • marketing priorities
  • marketing process
  • marketing process optimization
  • marketing resource management
  • marketing return on investment
  • marketing ROI
  • marketing sales alignment
  • marketing service providers
  • marketing services
  • marketing services providers
  • marketing skills gap
  • marketing software
  • marketing software evaluation
  • marketing software industry trends
  • marketing software product reviews
  • marketing software selection
  • marketing software trends
  • marketing softwware
  • marketing suites
  • marketing system architecture
  • marketing system evaluation
  • marketing system ROI
  • marketing system selection
  • marketing systems
  • marketing technology
  • marketing tests
  • marketing tips
  • marketing to sales alignment
  • marketing training
  • marketing trends
  • marketing-sales integration
  • marketingpilot
  • marketo
  • marketo funding
  • marketo ipo
  • master data management
  • matching
  • maturity model
  • meaning based marketing
  • media mix models
  • message customization
  • metrics
  • micro-business marketing software
  • microsoft
  • microsoft dynamics crm
  • mid-tier marketing systems
  • mindmatrix
  • mintigo
  • mma
  • mobile marketing
  • mpm toolkit
  • multi-channel marketing
  • multi-language marketing
  • multivariate testing
  • natural language processing
  • neolane
  • net promoter score
  • network link analysis
  • next best action
  • nice systems
  • nimble crm
  • number of clients
  • nurture programs
  • officeautopilot
  • omnichannel marketing
  • omniture
  • on-demand
  • on-demand business intelligence
  • on-demand software
  • on-premise software
  • online advertising
  • online advertising optimization
  • online analytics
  • online marketing
  • open source bi
  • open source software
  • optimization
  • optimove
  • oracle
  • paraccel
  • pardot
  • pardot acquisition
  • partner relationship management
  • pay per click
  • pay per response
  • pedowitz group
  • pegasystems
  • performable
  • performance marketing
  • personalization
  • pitney bowes
  • portrait software
  • predictive analytics
  • predictive lead scoring
  • predictive modeling
  • privacy
  • prospect database
  • prospecting
  • qliktech
  • qlikview
  • qlikview price
  • raab guide
  • raab report
  • raab survey
  • Raab VEST
  • Raab VEST report
  • raab webinar
  • reachedge
  • reachforce
  • real time decision management
  • real time interaction management
  • real-time decisions
  • real-time interaction management
  • realtime decisions
  • recommendation engines
  • relationship analysis
  • reporting software
  • request for proposal
  • reseller marketing automation
  • response attribution
  • revenue attribution
  • revenue generation
  • revenue performance management
  • rfm scores
  • rightnow
  • rightwave
  • roi reporting
  • role of experts
  • rule-based systems
  • saas software
  • saffron technology
  • sales automation
  • sales best practices
  • sales enablement
  • sales force automation
  • sales funnel
  • sales lead management association
  • sales leads
  • sales process
  • sales prospecting
  • salesforce acquires exacttarget
  • salesforce.com
  • salesgenius
  • sap
  • sas
  • score cards
  • search engine optimization
  • search engines
  • self-optimizing systems
  • selligent
  • semantic analysis
  • semantic analytics
  • sentiment analysis
  • service oriented architecture
  • setlogik
  • setlogik acquisition
  • silverpop
  • silverpop engage
  • silverpop engage b2b
  • simulation
  • sisense prismcubed
  • sitecore
  • small business marketing
  • small business software
  • smarter commerce
  • smartfocus
  • soa
  • social campaign management
  • social crm
  • social marketing
  • social marketing automation
  • social marketing management
  • social media
  • social media marketing
  • social media measurement
  • social media monitoring
  • social media roi
  • social network data
  • software as a service
  • software costs
  • software deployment
  • software evaluation
  • software satisfaction
  • software selection
  • software usability
  • software usability measurement
  • Spredfast
  • stage-based measurement
  • state-based systems
  • surveillance technology
  • sweet suite
  • swyft
  • sybase iq
  • system deployment
  • system design
  • system implementation
  • system requirements
  • system selection
  • tableau software
  • technology infrastructure
  • techrigy
  • Tenbase
  • teradata
  • test design
  • text analysis
  • training
  • treehouse international
  • trigger marketing
  • twitter
  • unica
  • universal behaviors
  • unstructured data
  • usability assessment
  • user interface
  • vendor comparison
  • vendor evaluation
  • vendor evaluation comparison
  • vendor rankings
  • vendor selection
  • vendor services
  • venntive
  • vertica
  • visualiq
  • vocus
  • vtrenz
  • web analytics
  • web contact management
  • Web content management
  • web data analysis
  • web marketing
  • web personalization
  • Web site design
  • whatsnexx
  • woopra
  • youcalc
  • zoho
  • zoomix

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (55)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (5)
    • ►  October (4)
    • ►  September (3)
    • ►  August (5)
    • ►  July (5)
    • ►  June (5)
    • ►  May (6)
    • ►  April (6)
    • ►  March (1)
    • ►  February (6)
    • ►  January (5)
  • ►  2012 (56)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (3)
    • ►  October (6)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  August (7)
    • ►  July (3)
    • ►  June (4)
    • ►  May (5)
    • ►  April (3)
    • ►  March (4)
    • ►  February (8)
    • ►  January (5)
  • ►  2011 (74)
    • ►  December (9)
    • ►  November (8)
    • ►  October (6)
    • ►  September (5)
    • ►  August (5)
    • ►  July (3)
    • ►  June (6)
    • ►  May (5)
    • ►  April (6)
    • ►  March (8)
    • ►  February (7)
    • ►  January (6)
  • ▼  2010 (75)
    • ►  December (9)
    • ►  November (9)
    • ►  October (5)
    • ►  September (6)
    • ►  August (7)
    • ►  July (3)
    • ▼  June (6)
      • LoopFuse Offers Free Marketing Automation System: ...
      • Saffron Technology Organizes Data into Memories
      • Privacy: Does Anybody Care?
      • Checklists for Selecting a Marketing Automation Sy...
      • Using a Purchase Funnel to Measure Marketing Effec...
      • Centrifuge Systems Offers Powerful, Flexible Link ...
    • ►  May (9)
    • ►  April (4)
    • ►  March (6)
    • ►  February (6)
    • ►  January (5)
  • ►  2009 (96)
    • ►  December (2)
    • ►  November (4)
    • ►  October (5)
    • ►  September (9)
    • ►  August (7)
    • ►  July (16)
    • ►  June (9)
    • ►  May (5)
    • ►  April (11)
    • ►  March (11)
    • ►  February (11)
    • ►  January (6)
  • ►  2008 (59)
    • ►  December (6)
    • ►  November (3)
    • ►  October (8)
    • ►  September (1)
    • ►  August (5)
    • ►  July (8)
    • ►  June (5)
    • ►  May (5)
    • ►  April (6)
    • ►  March (3)
    • ►  February (3)
    • ►  January (6)
  • ►  2007 (84)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (6)
    • ►  October (6)
    • ►  September (1)
    • ►  August (4)
    • ►  July (7)
    • ►  June (16)
    • ►  May (20)
    • ►  April (20)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile